When selecting a toilet for your bathroom, one of the most important decisions you’ll need to make is whether to choose a one piece round toilet or a two piece round toilet. Both types offer unique benefits, so understanding their differences will help you make an informed choice that best suits your needs.
In this article, we will compare one piece round toilets and two piece round toilets, discussing their advantages in terms of ease of installation, durability, design, and overall performance.
What Is a One Piece Round Toilet?
A one piece round toilet is exactly what the name suggests: a single, integrated unit where the tank and bowl are fused together. This design contrasts with the more traditional two piece round toilet, where the tank and bowl are separate and connected during installation.
The one piece round toilet has become increasingly popular due to its sleek appearance and space-saving benefits. It’s ideal for bathrooms with limited space or where simplicity is preferred. The seamless design of a round one piece toilet eliminates the need for additional joints or seams, providing a more modern and minimalist look.
If you’re looking for a modern one piece round toilet, you’ll be pleased with the seamless construction and the high-quality materials used. This style has become a go-to choice for contemporary bathrooms that require a clean, minimalist aesthetic.
What Is a Two Piece Round Toilet?
In contrast, a two piece round toilet features a separate tank and bowl. These two parts are connected during installation and are often easier to transport and handle compared to one piece round toilets. The round two piece toilet design has been around for decades and is typically more common due to its straightforward installation process and versatility.
Design and Appearance
The design of a toilet plays an important role in how it fits into your bathroom decor. When it comes to choosing between a one piece round toilet and a two piece round toilet, the design is a key factor to consider.
- One Piece Round Toilet:
The one piece round toilet is known for its sleek, modern look. The seamless construction offers a minimalist aesthetic, which works particularly well in contemporary bathrooms. The integrated design means fewer lines and joints, resulting in a more cohesive and streamlined appearance. This makes the one piece round toilet a popular choice for those looking to enhance the overall design of their bathroom while maintaining a clean and modern feel. - Two Piece Round Toilet:
On the other hand, the two piece round toilet tends to have a more traditional appearance. While modern designs are available, they often feature visible seams where the tank and bowl connect. Some homeowners appreciate this look for its classic and familiar design. It’s a practical choice for those who don’t mind a slightly bulkier appearance in exchange for ease of installation and versatility in repairs.
Installation Process
One of the key differences between a one piece round toilet and a two piece round toilet is the installation process. Installation can impact both the time required and the difficulty of the task.
- One Piece Round Toilet:
The one piece round toilet is generally heavier and bulkier than its two piece round toilet counterpart. As a result, it can be more difficult to handle during installation, especially for DIY enthusiasts. The toilet needs to be placed as a single unit, and any mistakes during installation could lead to leaks or improper fitting. This means that if you’re not experienced, professional installation is often recommended.
However, once installed, the one piece round toilet offers ease of maintenance due to fewer joints and crevices. There’s less chance for dirt or grime to accumulate, which makes cleaning more efficient.
If you prefer a modern one piece round toilet, you will likely find that these toilets come with advanced flushing mechanisms, which also help reduce maintenance efforts in the long run.
- Two Piece Round Toilet:
The two piece round toilet is generally easier to install because it’s lighter and has a separate tank and bowl. Each component is easier to manage and transport, and they can be positioned separately before being connected. For DIY installations, this design offers a more straightforward process.
Additionally, a two piece round toilet can be easier to repair because you can replace individual parts (such as the tank or the bowl) without needing to replace the entire unit. If you need to swap out components, this can be a more cost-effective solution.
Durability and Maintenance
When it comes to durability, both the one piece round toilet and the two piece round toilet offer strong, long-lasting materials, but there are some notable differences in how they hold up over time.
- One Piece Round Toilet:
A one piece round toilet is often considered more durable in terms of its overall structure. Since it is made from a single piece, there’s less chance of the tank and bowl becoming disconnected, reducing the risk of leaks or cracks over time. The design also makes it less susceptible to wear and tear in areas where dirt or grime can build up, as there are fewer seams to clean.
However, if a one piece round bowl toilet becomes damaged, it typically requires replacing the entire unit rather than just a single part. This can make repairs more expensive.
- Two Piece Round Toilet:
The two piece round toilet offers slightly more flexibility when it comes to repairs. Since the tank and bowl are separate, if one part becomes damaged, you can simply replace that component rather than the entire toilet. This can save you money on repairs, especially if the damage is confined to the tank.
However, over time, the connection between the tank and the bowl can weaken, potentially leading to leaks. This isn’t typically a problem with a one piece round toilet, as the seamless design prevents such issues from occurring.
Price
In general, two piece round toilets tend to be more affordable than one piece round toilets, due to their simpler design and easier manufacturing process. If you’re working within a tight budget, the two piece round toilet can offer significant savings without compromising on basic functionality.
On the other hand, a one piece round toilet usually comes at a higher price point, reflecting its modern design, ease of maintenance, and durability. However, many homeowners consider this added cost to be worth the investment due to the aesthetic and functional benefits it provides.
Water Efficiency and Flushing Performance
Both one piece round toilets and two piece round toilets can be equipped with modern, efficient flushing systems that conserve water and improve performance. Many of these toilets feature dual-flush mechanisms that allow you to choose between a lighter flush for liquids and a stronger flush for solids.
- One Piece Round Toilet:
A round one piece toilet often features advanced flushing systems, such as gravity-flush or pressure-assisted mechanisms, which are highly effective at eliminating waste with minimal water usage. These toilets are designed to be efficient, making them an environmentally-friendly option. - Two Piece Round Toilet:
The round two piece toilet also offers high-efficiency flushing systems, but the effectiveness of the flush may vary depending on the model. Some older designs may use more water than round toilets, though new models are equipped with dual-flush systems that are just as efficient as their one-piece counterparts.
Which Is the Best Option for You?
Choosing between a one piece round toilet and a two piece round toilet ultimately comes down to your personal preferences, your budget, and the specific requirements of your bathroom. Here are a few factors to consider:
Choose a One Piece Round Toilet If:
You prefer a sleek, modern design.
You want fewer seams and joints to clean.
You don’t mind a slightly higher upfront cost.
You want a more durable, integrated unit with fewer chances for leaks.
Choose a Two Piece Round Toilet If:
You are on a budget and looking for an affordable option.
You want flexibility in repairs and component replacements.
You prefer easier installation for DIY projects.
You like the classic look and feel of a traditional toilet design.
Conclusion
Both one piece round toilets and two piece round toilets have their own advantages and drawbacks, making them suitable for different bathroom styles and user preferences.
The one piece round toilet stands out for its modern design, ease of maintenance, and durable structure. On the other hand, the two piece round toilet offers affordability, ease of installation, and flexibility when it comes to repairs.
